As mentioned in a previous post, Louisiana held its annual All-State Band and Orchestra auditions on Saturday, and I was asked to judge horn and tuba. I have judged these auditions before, but this time I have a blog with which to share a few of my thoughts about the day. Things got off to an early start with a judges meeting at 7:30am, and the auditions began at 8:30. Overall the auditions were quite fun and interesting to listen to — Louisiana has some very talented young horn and tuba players! We judged from 8:30am until 3:30pm, with only a short break for lunch. The auditions were screened, with a monitor in the room at all times to relay instructions from the judges to the players. Repertoire for each audition was as follows: 1) Major scales in all keys (all 2 octaves for horn) 2) Excerpts from two prepared etudes, one lyrical and one technical, and 3) Sight-reading. Although the audition times were scheduled at six minutes each, realistically this was not enough time, with most of the auditions lasting somewhere between eight and ten minutes. Needless to say, we fell behind schedule almost immediately, and I do apologize to all of the auditioning students for this problem. As a judge I think it is important not to rush the players — I could tell just from listening to breathing that many of the students were quite nervous — and rushing them through the audition would have only made things worse. Perhaps in the future the audition time slots will be extended slightly to accommodate playing all of the required materials. I didn’t have time to make any notes during the auditions – both I and the other judge had our hands full tallying our scores, and the auditions proceeded pretty much back-to-back. I do however have a few general comments about each part of the audition — scales, prepared etudes, and sight-reading. If you are planning on auditioning for All-State in Louisiana in the future perhaps these thoughts will be helpful to you.
It can be tricky finding the balance between speed and accuracy, but if you go too slowly on scales the danger is that the judges may assume that you aren’t prepared and simply going slow because you don’t know the scales thoroughly. On the other hand, if you speed through the scales and don’t play every note clearly, you won’t get the full points either. Pay attention to tone quality and intonation on your scales as well. This is very important – you want to play your scales cleanly and accurately, but that should never involve sacrificing tone quality and intonation. As a judge I would much rather hear scales played a bit more slowly, provided they are in tune and with a good sound. You want to be consistent, but not mechanical.
II. Prepared Etudes
If I had to make only one comment about the etudes I heard on Saturday it would be that the slow, lyrical etudes often sounded less prepared than the fast, technical etudes. Perhaps this is because the lyrical etudes somehow seemed to the players less interesting and not as flashy as the technical ones, thus meriting less practice time. I would say that the opposite is true – the lyrical side of our playing often takes much longer and more working out than the technical things do, and playing one beautiful phrase in an audition is often worth just as much (or more) than blasting out lots of high, fast notes.
As promised, I do plan to write more about this topic in the future – once I get my head around things a bit more. For now, all I can say is that the sight-reading seemed to pose a number of challenges to the players this year. I will offer a few basic hints at this point, hopefully with more details to follow. First, absolutely pay attention to the key signature(s). If there is a key change that is one of the big things the judges will be listening for. Same thing goes for meter changes as well. Unless specified, you must keep a steady tempo throughout the duration of the excerpt. Remember that these are basically ensemble auditions, and poor rhythm will wreck an ensemble far more quickly than the occasional missed note. I would not recommend going back to try to “fix” anything you miss along the way – simply keep subdividing in a steady tempo and continue through the excerpt. As a high school student one of the best things you can do right now to improve your sight reading is work on ear training. Check out websites like Good Ear.com and Learn2hear.org for free ear training exercises.
That does it for my general comments. Congratulations to everyone who auditioned this year, and keep practicing!